← Resources
Industrial comparison

Atmospheric or vacuum plasma

Sealed chamber or torch on the conveyor? The choice is not decided by physics, but by the geometry of your parts and the cycle time of your line.

Read 7 min Marine Queffeulou, Ph.D. Kalego Solutions · Quebec
2 plasma architectures to choose between before investing
0 pump-down time in an atmospheric configuration
3 engineering criteria that actually decide the choice
IP67 ingress protection level targeted in the case study below
The essentials in 30 seconds
  • Vacuum: the plasma envelops the part from every angle. Unbeatable on complex geometries, but the treatment runs in batches.
  • Atmospheric: the head mounts on the robot and treats parts as they travel down the conveyor. No chamber, no door to close, no pump-down.
  • The real trade-off comes down to three points: part geometry, robotic integration and cycle time. The physics of the treatment itself is comparable.
Contents
  1. Two technologies, two philosophies
  2. The match-up, point by point
  3. Application case: sealing an inverter
01. Two architectures

Two technologies, two philosophies

You need to improve adhesion on a critical component. Plasma is the solution your R&D has validated. But once you face the equipment suppliers, the dilemma sets in: do you enclose your parts in a sealed chamber (vacuum) or bring the plasma straight to your conveyor (atmospheric)?

1. Vacuum

Batch treatment

Parts are placed in a chamber. The air is pumped out, a gas is injected and ionised. The plasma fills the whole space and envelops the part from every angle.

2. Atmospheric

In-line treatment

No chamber required. A torch or DBD head blows the plasma straight onto the surface, at plant pressure, often mounted on a robotic arm.

02. Engineering criteria

The match-up: point by point

Part geometry

Ability to treat cavities and blind holes.

Winner: vacuum

The gas reaches absolutely everywhere — ideal for complex medical components or coils.

Robotic integration

Compatibility with 6-axis or SCARA automation.

Winner: atmospheric

The plasma head bolts straight onto the robot end effector. The treatment slots into the existing tool path.

Cycle time (throughput)

Execution speed on a production line.

Winner: atmospheric

Immediate. No dead time spent closing a door and pumping down a vacuum chamber.

The technical term

Takt time cycle time

The rhythm imposed on a production line to meet demand: the maximum time each station has before it must pass the part on. In automotive, it is often counted in tens of seconds.

What this means for you: It is the number that eliminates a technology. A batch process that forces parts off the line will not fit a tight takt time, however good its treatment quality.

03. In the field

Application case: sealing an inverter

Picture the assembly line for a high-voltage power controller for electric vehicles. The aluminium housing has to be sealed with a silicone gasket (FIPG) to guarantee absolute IP67 protection against water and dust.

  • The vacuum approach: it would mean stopping the line, grouping housings into batches of 50, loading them into a machine, waiting for pump-down, then feeding them back onto the conveyor. Incompatible with automotive takt time.
  • The atmospheric solution: the robot arm that lays down the silicone bead carries a plasma nozzle. On the first pass, the robot activates the aluminium channel. On the second pass, immediately after, it lays the silicone. Adhesion is excellent, with no break in the material flow.
What this changes on the line
  • The treatment slots into the robot's existing tool path: no extra station, no manual rework.
  • No break in the material flow: parts never leave the conveyor.
  • Activation and gasket deposition happen in two consecutive passes, inside the same cell.
Key terms

The vocabulary, decoded

Batch treatment

Parts are grouped, taken off the line, treated together in a chamber, then fed back in.

In-line treatment

Treatment happens in the flow, on the conveyor, without interrupting production.

Takt time

The cycle time imposed on each station of a line to keep up with delivery rate.

FIPG

Formed In Place Gasket: a sealing bead dispensed directly onto the part, then cured in place.

A note on method. The figures quoted are orders of magnitude observed in an atmospheric pressure DBD configuration. They vary with the material, the geometry of the part and the line speed: we measure and document the exact parameters on your own samples before making any recommendation.

Keep reading

More in this series

Foundational article

Plasma surface treatment, explained

How plasma modifies a surface at the nanoscale to improve adhesion, wettability and cleanliness. Read 8 minRead →
Application case

Improving adhesion before bonding or printing

Why DBD plasma replaced chemical primers and abrasion in surface preparation. Read 9 minRead →

Validate your architecture.

Talk to our systems engineers to define the optimal integration — speed, dosing, trajectory — of your future equipment.

Contact engineering
Free assessment